How to Build an Effective Tax-Loss Harvesting Strategy
As a Principal Wealth Advisor at Compound Planning, Nicholas Garcia has spent 16+ years helping individuals and families navigate equity compensation, liquidity events, and comprehensive financial planning.
Say “Max” has $2 million spread across stocks: This year, some are up; some are down.
While some investors might just wait for the declining stocks to bounce back, Max's advisor makes a move: He sells the losing positions, locks in that loss, and reinvests the cash.
Max's portfolio barely changed, but now he has a "loss" he can use to offset a current or future gain (e.g., the sale of a house, a tender offer, or selling shares from equity compensation).
That's called tax-loss harvesting. If Max consistently sells losing stocks, he'll accumulate a "basket of losses" he can use to lower the tax impact of large gain events — and the bigger the basket, the bigger dent he can make on his next tax bill.
Done consistently over time, tax-loss harvesting can lower the taxes Max pays along the way. Those savings may be called tax alpha.
Timing matters, though. Losses take time — and market movement — to build up, and you never know exactly when you'll need to use them. The earlier Max starts, the more prepared he’ll be when a gain comes along.
Below, we dive into what you should know if you’re thinking about tax-loss harvesting.
Key takeaways:
• Proactively planning losses can offset taxes on gains down the road. You’re best prepared for capital gains events if you’ve accumulated losses over the years.
• Ongoing contributions make tax-loss harvesting sustainable. Regular contributions (from a bonus, vesting equity, or routine savings) keep resetting the cost basis on new shares, which is what lets the strategy keep working.
• Tax-loss harvesting isn’t right for everyone. If you’re retired with no gains, or you want simplicity, tax-loss harvesting might not be the right fit. But that should be a decision, not a default.
How Does Tax-Loss Harvesting Work?
Basically, you’re selling investments at a loss to offset capital gains elsewhere in your portfolio. Think of it like positives and negatives: If you have $900 in capital gains this year but realized $100 in losses, you're only taxed on the net $800 in gains.
Tax-loss harvesting, as a strategy, aims to reduce what you owe at tax time.
Some important mechanics to understand before you use a tax-loss harvesting strategy:
- Its effectiveness depends on your investment structure/account
If you have ETFs, there's rarely a lot to harvest — the funds usually move together, so it's uncommon for one to dip into a loss while the others don't. But with direct indexing, you own hundreds of individual stocks within an index; because those stocks move independently, there are frequently small losses you can capture. - Losses carry forward
All the losses you accumulated don’t go away at the end of the year. They roll over into the future. That’s why starting to build your basket of losses early makes sense — the longer you do it, the bigger your “bank” is when equity vesting, a business sale, or another capital gains event comes, which means you can offset more of the tax impact. (Plus, even with no capital gains to offset, up to $3,000 of losses can count against ordinary income each year.) - The direct indexing “trap”
We often hear from investors who are worried that, with direct indexing, they’ll get stuck holding a few huge, low-basis positions. But that’s only true if you invest a lump sum once — over time, you can end up with a few positions carrying large embedded gains and few ways to harvest losses. When you contribute regularly — from a bonus, equity vesting, or routine savings — each new contribution resets the cost basis on the shares it buys. That lets them both harvest losses and rebalance by buying underweight positions with new cash instead of selling appreciated ones. - The benefit builds over years
Don’t get antsy — it takes time. Tax-loss harvesting can lower your taxes as you bank losses over several years. How much depends on markets, your taxes, and whether you have gains to offset.
When Should I Take Advantage of Tax-Loss Harvesting?
If you're a tech employee with equity compensation, you might have waves of capital gain events ahead. Getting a strategy in place now helps you build a basket of losses that can offset those gains later.
If you’re a business owner eyeing a sale, while your timeline may be longer, you still want a basket of losses built to offset that gain.
And if you're just investing regularly and expect to rebalance or eventually sell — the strategy is still worth getting smart on.
Like all complex financial strategies, tax-loss harvesting isn’t for everyone, and it works best under specific conditions.
When tax-loss harvesting may make sense:
(1) You know you're going to have capital gain events in the future. This could include:
- equity from a liquidity event or IPO
- the sale of a business
- inherited assets
- real estate gains
- fund distributions
- rebalancing periods where gains get realized
(2) You're making ongoing contributions to direct indexing. You frequently reset your cost basis by buying more positions at different prices and rebalancing.
When tax-loss harvesting might not make sense:
- You’re retired and aren't going to have large capital gain events because you’re not anticipating a business sale, home sale, or any workplace equity events. (Though it can still make sense with larger account sizes where there's rebalancing.)
- You put in one lump sum into direct indexing and never add anything besides that. Over time, the positions that recover end up with big gains and no new cost basis to work with. This is what negative articles in the news are actually talking about.
- You prefer to keep your financial approach simple, and you're okay giving up the ability to offset gains when they come.
Should I Combine Direct Indexing and Tax-Loss Harvesting?
This isn't really an either/or choice. Direct indexing generally creates more tax-loss harvesting opportunities than ETFs.
The key question is really: “How much do I want to harvest, and is the extra complexity worth it?”
Direct indexing used to be expensive, often costing 1% or more in fees, which kept investors in ETFs. But today, many platforms charge close to what a low-cost ETF does — that means the cost of getting that added tax benefit is lower than it used to be.
The direct indexing vs. ETF question isn’t a question of cost anymore.
If tax-loss harvesting is right for you, and you can make ongoing contributions to your investments, combining direct-indexing and tax-loss harvesting can be worth it. If you'd rather keep things simple and are comfortable giving up some tax efficiency, an ETF-only approach is still a fair choice.
What Using Your “Basket of Losses” Looks Like
There are a few common scenarios where our advisors might encourage clients to consider a TLH strategy.
Scenario #1: When equity compensation is available
When equity compensation holders have a separate, diversified portfolio running under a direct-indexing strategy, they're building a basket of losses that they can use the moment a liquidity window opens for their equity.
Because liquidity windows can move quickly; having the losses prepared makes a difference. At fast-growing private companies, for example, a new funding round can trigger a blackout that closes a window with little notice. Having losses already banked gives you a clearer picture of the tax cost when you can sell.
Post-liquidity event, harvesting losses is often about the long game: You can look at it as “build during the down, deploy during the recovery.”
Scenario #2: The business owner planning a sale
Selling your business can take years — the exit planning can take years too. But that runway before a sale is exactly when you want to build up your basket of losses.
When you do sell, you're likely realizing a significant capital gain, and those banked losses can offset part of it. A lot of business-sale tax planning focuses on deal structure — how the sale itself is arranged — but those losses you’ve built up in your personal portfolio are a lever for reducing what you owe.
Have the tax-loss harvesting conversation early during exit planning, not at the point of sale.
Scenario #3: The lawyer or high-income professional
Doctors, lawyers, business owners, and other high-income professionals can also benefit from a tax-loss harvesting strategy, even without a large liquidity event on the horizon.
Normal, ongoing investing generates taxable gains in subtle ways:
- Regularly rebalancing a taxable portfolio. Over time, your investments drift from your target allocation as some grow faster than others — for example, stocks outpacing bonds. To bring the portfolio back in line, you might sell some of the bigger position: If it’s appreciated, then you’ve made a capital gain.
- Getting capital gain distributions from funds. Even if you never sell a share, mutual funds (and, less often, ETFs) can distribute capital gains to shareholders: You can owe tax on gains you didn't decide to realize.
- Selling appreciated positions. Trimming a position that's grown over time, for any reason, can trigger a gain.
- Normal portfolio management at high income levels. The larger the account, the more rebalancing and position changes tend to happen — and the larger those resulting gains tend to be.
None of these feel like a “liquidity event,” but they all generate gains that a basket of losses can offset.
Scenario #4: Gifted appreciated assets
Think of this in terms of wealth transfers, like when a family moves appreciated assets into an irrevocable trust for their heirs. When assets are gifted before someone passes, the recipient takes on the original cost basis instead of the stepped-up cost basis they'd get by inheriting it at death. Since there's no step-up in this case, the recipient eventually receives not just the asset, but the built-in gain that comes with it.
When you’re sitting on a big built-in gain, you have two ways to draw down that position while managing the tax: Sell it off gradually, or donate it. If you're selling, then a basket of losses can keep your tax bill more manageable.
Scenario #5: Dual-income households
Note: This scenario could apply to anyone within scenarios 1-4 as an additional cause for tax-loss harvesting.
Households with multiple income streams can make your finances more complicated. If either or both people in a partnership fit into scenarios 1–4 above, then the case for building the basket of losses early is stronger: You may need to plan for several different gain events, often on different timelines.
For example, if one partner works in tech and the other owns a business, gain events may arrive on different schedules and from different sources. To build a strategy that accounts for both earners, you need to be looking at both portfolios together.
At Compound, we look at a complete balance sheet across all of a client's accounts. That full picture helps make the plan effective: without it, you might be harvesting losses in one account while missing the gains in another that they could offset.
How Tax-loss Harvesting Can Benefit You
When you plan over multiple years, you can set yourself up to keep more of your gains when the right conditions arise.
Whether you're a tech employee watching a narrow exercise window, a business owner a few years out from a sale, or a dual-income household with multiple gain events, the best time to start building your basket of losses is now — not after the next liquidity event.
The strategy works best when you're looking at the full picture: every account, every gain event, every timeline together.
See everything in one place in the Compound Dashboard.
FAQs
I already had a liquidity event. Is it too late to take advantage of tax-loss harvesting?
No, but you’ll have fewer banked losses to work with to offset your gains. Coming in late isn't wrong; it just means less runway. The better move is usually to start building now for the gain events still ahead of you.
What happens to my basket of losses if I don’t have a large gain event?
They generally carry forward from year to year for as long as you live.. Unused losses can offset ordinary income up to $3,000 per year, and the rest carries forward. When a gain event happens, the losses are waiting for it.
If I sell one stock at a loss and immediately buy another, does that cancel my tax-loss harvesting benefit?
The wash-sale rule disallows your loss if you buy the same or a substantially identical security within 30 days before or after the sale, including in an IRA or a spouse’s account. Usually the disallowed loss is added to the cost basis of the new shares; if the repurchase is in an IRA, it’s generally lost for good. To keep the loss, you can buy a similar but not substantially identical investment right away, or wait 31 days to buy back the same one.
Compound Planning is an SEC-registered investment adviser. Content is informational only, not advice or a solicitation. Investing involves risk, including principal loss. Past performance is no guarantee of future results.
