When should I consider ETFs vs. direct indexing?
Many people start their investing journey with exchange-traded funds (ETFs). Historically, these have been a low-cost, easy entry point to get started with investing. Some of the most popular ETFs today are pegged to the S&P 500, Nasdaq 100, or bundles of tech company stocks.
A slightly more complex approach is direct indexing, where, rather than invest in a basket of stocks that track an index, you individually buy the stocks that make up an index.
If you’re considering tax-loss harvesting (TLH) as a financial strategy, you may want to consider a direct indexing approach. Here’s why.
ETFs: When you buy an ETF, you buy everything in it; there’s no selection of the securities within. You’re typically holding ~8 positions that track an index, and those positions are unlikely to move 5% or more over a few months. That makes it difficult for you to trade away stocks at a loss in order to offset capital gains.
While ETF-based TLH does exist, it’s generally on a smaller scale, and mostly happens around rebalancing periods. It doesn’t provide the tactical, ongoing harvesting that direct indexing does.
You might prefer ETFs because they’re simpler, and you’re willing to sacrifice potential benefits of tax-loss harvesting. It’s just important that you’re choosing ETFs for a reason instead of defaulting to them.
Direct indexing: As capital gain events happen, you may want to harvest losses. This is easier to do with direct indexing. That’s because with direct indexing, you own the individual stocks — and those can move 5%–100% over a short time period.
You’re also able to invest according to your beliefs and values (like excluding certain sectors, opting for U.S.-only, removing specific company names). ETFs do not let you select or reject individual investments.
Plus, the cost gap that kept investors from direct indexing is not a significant factor anymore: Now direct indexing runs at 10–20 basis points, close to ETF ranges.
Notably, you don’t have to pick just ETFs or just direct indexing: It’s a spectrum, not a binary.
The bottom line: The choice often comes down to simplicity (ETFs) vs. the ability to customize and harvest more actively long term (direct indexing). It’s also a question of time horizon’s: tax-loss harvesting’s impact can be large, but it’s clearest over the course of several years, as your basket of losses grows.
When your advisor has visibility into your complete financial picture — not just one or two accounts — they can help you configure allocation targets, capital gains budgets, and any exclusions that reflect your values or situation. Your investments run automatically in the background from there.
See everything in one place in the Compound Dashboard.
FAQs
How is direct indexing different from managing ETFs?
With ETFs, you own a bundled position — you can't harvest losses on the individual stocks inside it. Direct indexing means you own each stock separately, so there are far more opportunities to harvest losses as individual positions move. Your advisor isn't doing something different; the structure of what you own is what changes.
Is there a minimum account size where direct indexing starts to make sense?
Generally, direct indexing becomes cost-competitive with ETFs around $250,000–$500,000 in a taxable account, especially now that management fees have come down to 10–20 basis points. Below that threshold, ETFs are often a starting point, but that’s worth revisiting as your account grows, particularly if you know gain events are on the horizon.
